Captain’s Choice Aftershave Samples (12ml)

4.13 out of 5 based on 8 customer ratings
(8 customer reviews)


SHIPPING RESTRICTIONS: This product contains alcohol, which is potentially hazardous for shipping. We can not ship it outside of the continental USA. If you are an international customer, this item will be refunded and will not be shipped.

Clear selection

Product Description

Captain’s Choice samples? Yes, please!


8 reviews for Captain’s Choice Aftershave Samples (12ml)

  1. 5 out of 5


    Another great way to find that perfect bay rum scent, though in all honesty, the Lime was far and away my favorite. Good burn, especially with the Cat O’Nine Tails. Scent last a moderate time. Great product,

  2. 5 out of 5


    I got the Captain’s Choice Sandalwood sample and I Love this scent. I’ve tried all their other scents. This Sandalwood and their Bay Rum Scents are my favorites. This Sandalwood aftershave has a natural, pure and clean scent. Leaving a fresh and soothing feeling on your face.

  3. 5 out of 5


    My first time trying Captain’s Choice Bay Rum…An absolutely excellent decision on my part. Do yourself a favor and get it. It will put some hair on your bare, adolescent chest!

  4. 5 out of 5


    I was pleasantly surprised how much I enjoyed this sample pack!
    The spray bottles they come in make for an extremely easy application, and prevent any wasting that could occur from over-pouring the sample into your hand.

    Lime: Very refreshing scent and feel after a shave. I wouldn’t mind the scent being a bit stronger as it doesn’t linger very long, but nonetheless, it is a great aftershave. Perfect for those who prefer mild scents.

    Sandalwood: One of my favorite scents, the Captain’s Choice Sandalwood does not disappoint. I found myself re-applying this aftershave throughout the day.

    North: This one surprised me. I was unsure at first if the juniper would make it smell too much like I just splashed gin on myself– this was not so. Very crisp and piney, this is a great “outdoorsman” aftershave.

    Bay Rum: As an avid bay rum user and maker, I was anxious to try this one. Great classic bay rum scent with a sharp bite that soothes very quickly. An easy go-to if you are trying to decide which aftershave to use.

    Cat O’ Nine Tails: As the name suggests, this one has an incredible bite to it! The strongest and longest lasting of the five aftershaves– not for those who want a subtle scent. Applied it once, and I smelled it the rest of the day.

  5. 4 out of 5


    I received three sample scents, they were Bay Rum, Cat O’ Nine Tails & Sandalwood. The Bay Rum was a light Bay Rum that seemed to have a fragrance of flowers in it. I did not care for it. It was quite different from my favorite Bay Rum from Clubman. The Cat O’ Nine Tails had a strong menthol burn as advertised. It also stayed with me for the entire day as another reviewer mentioned. My son thought it smelled a little like Christmas. Once he said that, I realized there was a nutmeg-like scent in there. Leather and nutmeg were the two strongest fragrances I could detect. I’ll save this one for December. The Sandalwood was my favorite of the three. It was a light-creamy sandalwood. Very pleasant. I think most people would like any of the three, however, my strongest recommendation goes to the Sandalwood.

  6. 3 out of 5


    I ordered a few bay rum samples from various companies and sadly, the Captain’s Choice was the one I liked the least. As an aftershave it does well which is why I gave three stars. Had it been on scent alone I would have given two stars as the Captain’s Choice Bay Rum is just too clove heavy for me and seems to overpower everything else in the aftershave.

  7. 1 out of 5


    Sorry but this smells nothing like lime should. It smells more like Windex to me honestly.

  8. 5 out of 5


    I went with the Cat o nine tails. After reading what bay rum is supposed to smell like, I never thought I would enjoy it.
    This scent is reeaaally cool. It has a smokiness to it, and a dark rich note. It is slightly savory with cinnamon.
    Now I am not sure if this coming in a spray bottle is intended this way but… I punch my nose closed and close my eyes, then blast about 3 sprays directly onto my face… WOW! What a freaking burn.
    This product is pure enjoyment.

Add a review