Captain’s Choice Sandalwood Aftershave (4oz)

4.38 out of 5 based on 8 customer ratings
(8 customer reviews)


Proudly made in America.

Samples available here!

SHIPPING RESTRICTIONS: This product contains alcohol, which is potentially hazardous for shipping. We can not ship it outside of the continental USA. If you are an international customer, this item will be refunded and will not be shipped.

11 in stock

Product Description

Here is a sandalwood aftershave that delivers a modern take on the classic scent.  This was developed with the help of dozens of volunteers over the course of several months.  The guys really liked this one and their wives / girlfriends told us they LOVED the scent on their man.  

Possessing a low key profile and gentle, lingering aroma here at last is a well balanced aftershave for the ages. With some zest upon application, the masculine scent evokes timeless tradition.  This is the ideal choice for a man who wants dependable aftershave performance with moisturizing comfort all day long. 

Packaged in a 4 oz classic amber bottle.

Don’t take our word for it, read what actual volunteers have to say:

“I enjoyed the fragrance A LOT – this is easily one of the best ones I have ever smelled.”    Nick

“The scent is straight sandalwood – I like the simplicity and the warmth of it. It opens with the expected alcohol burn, but dries down very quickly to a soothing, pure sandalwood. I can still smell a whiff or two a couple hours after my shave.”   Paul

“I really like  the subtleness of this aftershave.  After shaving and using this it keeps my skin feeling soft, my face still feels very moisturized hours after use.”   Greg

“Thanks for the sample of your new Sandalwood aftershave. My wife LOVES it. It has (as she told me) a nice subtle scent that is not overpowering. My adult son also liked it.”  James

“Your sandalwood  feels great on the face. This product is right on par with the other Captain’s Choice products that are in my rotation and right in there as far as making the face feel good. Bravo!!”  Erich

“I love the scent, very natural smell to it.  It is the perfect blend. I believe this is one of the best sandalwood aftershaves I have smelled.”  Dusty

“What a scent!  It is natural, woodsy and very masculine.  Not powdery in the least!  The scent retains a nice power for an hour or two and then fades but is still there.  I like the scent so much I reapply when I get home from work.”   Doug

“I think you have a winner here, I really like the smell.”   Hark

“It is a very calming aftershave experience which I welcome since I shave at night.”  Michael

“Topical application felt good going on, a nice clean feeling.  The scent is top notch and fades after an hour for me.”  Aaron

“It’s truly unique being a straight-up sandalwood and the moisturizing properties are there.  My wife really liked it and she is not a scent person at all.  In my opinion you nailed it with this sandalwood.”  Dan

“The scent is great and, for me, very enjoyable and pleasant.  I believe all around it is an exceptional product, the formula left my skin feeling great and the scent is very well balanced.”   Jim

“I  love every drop of this sandalwood.  You have a winner here!”  Dustin

8 reviews for Captain’s Choice Sandalwood Aftershave (4oz)

  1. 1 out of 5


    I’m not a fan of this one. To me, it smells like bug spray & moth balls. I get no Sandalwood at all. My wife thought the same. For Sandalwood, spring for the TOBS aftershave.

  2. 5 out of 5


    I like the straight forward approach of this scent. It’s a no-nonsense, straight forward sandlewood without much more beneath it. I’ve run this scent pass several friends and got excellent feedback. They all wanted to put it on.

  3. 5 out of 5


    Fantastic version of Sandalwood. Face feels great after every shave. Great scent and superb moisturizing properties. All qualities of each and every Captain’s Choice products. Definitely has a spot in my shave den.

  4. 5 out of 5


    Wonderful stuff! I really do love straight sandalwood scent not muddled down with a bunch of other smells and this hits the spot. Paired with wonderful skin feel this is a definite winner. Captain’s Choice has a gem on their hands! That paired with Maggard’s amazing service and shipping speed it’s a win/win!

  5. 5 out of 5


    I received a sample of this over the summer from the owner of the company Scott. This was my first experience with a sandalwood aftershave. I had some creams before, but they tend to be hit or miss as far as hitting the sandalwood scent is concerned. When I first opened this bottle I was overwhelmed with the authenticity of the sandalwood scent in this aftershave. The performance of this aftershave is excellent as well and it was very soothing for me. The scent of this aftershave is subtle, and will not interfere with whatever cologne you decide to wear, which is a plus for me. I think Scott developed a real winner and I could not be more pleased with this aftershave!

  6. 4 out of 5


    Great scent, great face feel. Only four **** because the scent is very short-lived, and not strong enough for my liking, but the lack of longevity and the mildness will be a + for some.

  7. 5 out of 5


    Sandalwood has never really been a scent I get too excited about. It is not that I dislike it, I just feel that it is not my type of scent. I purchased all of the Captain’s Choice AS samples from Maggard’s, and they have all been a home run. The best part about this particular one is the straightforward sandalwood scent. Nothing to throw it off course. Just pure sandalwood, nice and warm smelling. This will be the first time I have purchased a bottle of sandalwood scented anything in a long time. Same performance as all Captain’s Choice products. If you are a Sandalwood fan, I can’t imagine this not being a regular part of your routine. It will become part of mine, and Sandalwood isn’t even my favorite scent. This stuff is really fantastic.

  8. 5 out of 5


    I bought a sample of this earlier this year. My first thought the first time I used it was “Don’t buy a full-size bottle!”. I really didn’t like it, so it sat for 6 months. Then I tried it again. Hmmm, maybe this isn’t so bad. Used it a couple more times and I became addicted. I haven’t tried other sandalwood scented after shaves, so I can’t compare. The scent is strong enough for me and I can usually smell it around 3-4 hours after application. However, I stumbled on a way to smell it nearly all day. Just put some on your clothes. I spray a bit from my sample spray bottle on the armpit area and the scent is far more noticeable. It seems to work better on my moisture-wicking shirts than cotton shirts. I’m going to add this to my Christmas wish list. If the family doesn’t buy it for me I’ll buy one myself.

    Moral of the story…don’t write off a scent if you don’t like it at first. Put it away and revisit it a while later.

Add a review