Ogallala Bay Rum Shaving Soap 4.5oz

4.17 out of 5 based on 6 customer ratings
(6 customer reviews)


Made in USA

15 in stock

Product Description

One big 4.5 oz  round bar of Genuine Ogallala Bay Rum Shaving Soap.

Ogallala shaving soaps contain shea butter for a great smooth feel on your face. They are a big 3 inches in diameter.  If you have a mug that is a bit smaller, you can just whittle a bit off around the edges and throw the shavings in the mug with your soap to make it fit or melt for  about 30 seconds in a microwave-safe container and pour into your mug. (of course then you’ll need to let it cool before the first use).

Ogallala shaving soaps do not contain artificial coloring.

Need a place to store your new shaving soap?  We’ve checked to make sure this soap puck fits  in our 4oz Empty Jars that we currently have available! Add one to cart below for only $1.75!

6 reviews for Ogallala Bay Rum Shaving Soap 4.5oz

  1. 2 out of 5


    If your a bay rum fan your also very likely to appreciate Ogallala’s BR. I threw this puck in to round out an order.

    Pro: -Great scent, something special to savor
    -Price point is very reasonable

    Con: -Odd lather that tends to fizzle out on the face way too quickly. Ignore the initial “ready appearance” and work in a lot more water slowly. That will improve its performance all the way around including the fizzle out issue.
    -Well below par on protection and post shave performance. I am a sensitive skinned tallow lover and this performs like a very cheaply made vegan, IMO. I got nicks and razor burn like I hadn’t had for a long with this. All the other variables were well controlled.

    The fix:
    I salvaged this fine smelling mess by testing then mixing it in with a stick of Arko, a bit of distilled water and a few eyedroppers of Bay essential oil. I got the best of both worlds. The great scent and bargain lives on. The performance is very good now too. An unbelievable improvement came with the fine performing but very weakly scented tallow Arko product. Otherwise this was too poor to use for me. I believe all of their soap products are similar, with partially varied scents.

  2. 5 out of 5


    Excellent soap for their money, the smell fascinated many thanks for the excellent service

  3. 4 out of 5


    It smells great, lathers easily, any gives terrific glide. In short, it works very well. On the other hand, it gets used up pretty fast. Fair value.

  4. 5 out of 5


    I’m new to DE shaving but I’ve tried a few soaps and this is definitely my favorite. I mostly purchased it because I wondered what bay rum smelled like and this soap was a relatively cheap way to see if I like the smell. I LOVE the smell. It’s very clovey…I don’t really smell anything else which is probably why they have so many variations. It lathered really well and cleaned up nicely. It’s a smell I think other ladies would like too.

  5. 4 out of 5


    Very good soap for the money. Their Bay Rum is fantastic. This soap is not the best but far from lousy.

  6. 5 out of 5


    This is a really good soap especially for the price. Very nice Bay Rum scent. Nice thick and super slick lather. I get a really nice shave with this soap and the post shave is nice clean with a light scent left over.

Add a review