I tried four Lucky Tiger aftershaves. They were Aspen, Bay Rum, Face Tonic and the Vanishing Cream. Aspen has a very clean barbershop scent--sanitary but pleasant. The Bay Rum was slightly Bay Rummy. I still think the best Bay Rum is from Clubman. The Face Tonic must be made with Witch Hazel because there was no burn at all--which surprised me. In fact, Face Tonic was actually soothing after my straight razor shave. The fragrance had a slight orange scent to it which I liked. The Vanishing Cream was a new experience for me. It was a slightly hard paste (like partially dried Plato). When you rub it in your hands it warms and melts quickly after which you can apply it to your face. The cream appeared slightly white on my Caucasian face but rubbed in so that it disappeared altogether. It's fragrance was a slight menthol which did not burn at all. The cream was soothing. Regardless of which of the four Lucky Tigers I tried, each scent was very light and disappeared within 30-minutes (there will be no fragrance by the time you get to work). I would recommend all four, however, the Face Tonic and Vanishing Cream would be especially advantageous to those of you in cold climates. It will sooth your skin before going out in the cold winter weather.